Tuesday, April 26, 2011

Celebrate World Intellectual Property Day


April 26 is World Intellectual Property Day, and this year's theme is "Designing the Future." "Intellectual property" is writing, music, design, photography, and other creative works made by and therefore legally owned by an individual. The text and images on a blog, the original design of a ceramic or stitched piece, an illustration or art work, a recorded song--these are all examples of intellectual property that are legally protected from being reproduced.

Cassi of The Crafty Crow and Bella Dia just let me know that some of her blog posts (and a friend's and her sister's) and one of my tutorials had been copied almost in their entirety on another blog. The blog author included the photographs and word-for-word the instructions written by other authors. There was no link to the originating blog or any other indication of the original author of the posts.

I was stunned. The Crafty Crow provides a way to share free tutorials written by craft bloggers, and it's an amazing resource. But the site clearly attributes the source and links to the originating blog. Cassi had generously linked to my tutorial on the site. I had spent many, many hours taking the photographs, writing the text, and wrestling with Blogger on the formatting of the photographs so that the tutorial would be clear and easy to understand. I published the tutorial so that others could use it. I didn't publish it so that it could be stolen and passed off as someone else's work.

Cassi let me know how to get the stolen post taken down. I contacted the Wordpress blogger directly but also filled out a form through Wordpress that got the offending post removed. If you encounter this problem, the major blogging platforms provide a Digital Millennium Copyright Act Notice. This notice allows bloggers to report stolen posts that originate by Wordpress, Typepad, or Blogger (etc.) users. If you see a Wordpress blog that has stolen your work, you can report it on this form. The Typepad form is here. Blogger's is here. Google "Digital Millennium Copyright Act Notice" and the blogging platform to find the notice for other platforms.

I appreciate Cassi taking the time to let me know about the theft of my creative property and a way to address the issue. As a craft blogger, I feel that I am part of a generous, creative community.

I have looked into copyright issues a bit as a result of this incident. I found out that a published work such as a blog is automatically protected by copyright. A copyright notice, which I have added to the bottom of this page, is just a reminder to others that this work is protected. I have also added a restrictive Creative Commons license detailing how I'd like to share my text and images (as non-commercial links, and with attribution).

I urge you to educate yourself about intellectual property rights. The U.S. Patent and Trademark Office has several online publications that explain copyright issues. The World Intellectual Property Organization has an especially helpful pamphlet geared to kids (just my reading level!) that explains copyrights and what we can use from the Web in our own work. The U.K.'s Intellectual Property Office has some useful links related to protecting designs.

I know that this sort of stealing happens all the time. It's so easy to cut and paste someone's digital work. I also know that whatever measures we take to make copyright explicit will of course be ignored by the unscrupulous or uninformed. I hope that we can all use World Intellectual Property Day (and any opportunity we have) to spread the word about intellectual property rights. To stand up for our rights as blog creators and designers and artists as owners of the things we create.

25 comments:

Annette W. said...

Thanks for sharing this. Sorry to hear that your work was stolen!

Miri said...

This must be really upsetting, I hope it will be dealt with quickly!

pb said...

so informative. thanks so much for opening eyes and educating by way of passing it on.

The Sunshine Crew said...

Great info! Thanks!
Colleen

joanie said...

Oh no! Sorry to hear about the problems but glad it was taken care of in the end. Nice of Cassie to give you the heads up. Copying is such a rampant problem, the best way to fight it I've found is to just keep making, the copycats will never achieve the true satisfaction of creating. Jx

Slow Family Online said...

Thank you so much for writing this important post and for all the great information. I'm another blogger whose work was plagiarized on the same site as Cassi's. I so agree with you that this is a generous, creative community and that we have to protect all of our rights to the things we spend so much time and love creating and sharing. I'm also constantly awed by all the beautiful, *original* things online and know they will continue to inspire me.

Margie Oomen said...

thank you so much pat for your always eloquent and insightful way to post important topics. I am sorry this happened to you and cassi but happy to hear that you are dealing with it swiftly and what sounds to be soon effectively. I wish it was that simple on etsy. The other problem with etsy is that "calling another shop out" publicly is against the terms of contract and can lead to being disciplinary action by etsy and the revoking of your selling and buying rights. So until such time as I decide to pack up and move my shop, I am will remain quiet.

pam said...

Bloggers have helped themselves to my tutorials more than once and I for one find it infuriating.

Some bloggers seem to think if they give credit they can re-post a tutorial in it's entirety and it is OK. Others will duplicate the tutorial exactly using their own images.

I have written each of them and usually it has turned out that the "culprit" turns out to be a new blogger who just was uninformed.

What I am finding interesting here is that the name of the blogger in question here is not being given. How can the rest of us be vigilant in protecting our rights if we don't know who to watch out for?

Sorry if I sound harsh, but this sort of thing makes me furious. People like you and Cassi and many others I follow work very hard to produce excellent, original material. If a blogger is not capable of producing her own original content and feels compelled to steal the work of others, she should not have the privilege of being a part of this community.

Thank you for your informative post. I am linking to it now.

And I am sorry if I sound grumpy. My "mother lioness" instincts!

Sonja said...

Wow! What a timely post. This is happening to me right now. One of my most popular tutorials (Thanks in part to Cassi & The Crafty Crow) has been stolen and posted to a blog in another country. I have contacted the person who posted it and the hosting website to no avail. This particular person took all my pictures and converted my english text to spanish. She did include one link to my site (thats how I found out) not that that makes me feel much better. I frequently have people take one photo and post it with a link to my blog. While I don't love that they didn't take the time to ask, I am always pleased that they are at least saying something positive! I only wonder how many other sites my work is on without knowing.

Tina Robertson a/k/a Dynamic 2 Moms said...

I have to chime in too..It is happening to me RIGHT NOW and WOW Cassie THANK YOU for telling me..Don't these folks have some higher Being to answer to? How do they lay their head down on their pillow at night?

JUST ASK....if you want it and GIVE CREDIT where credit is due..

She didn't just copy SOME..she got almost the whole page AND what is she going to do--take credit for my lapbooks too as soon as she finishes downloading them and upload them to her site..I share it all for FREE.....How much other has she copied?

Here is my site
http://dynamic2moms.webs.com/toads.htm and LOOK HERE where it is NOW.
http://tugatnature.wordpress.com/2011/04/06/amphibians-toads/

Sherry Harmes said...

Thank you so much for this information. I haven't gotten a blog page yet, but it will be helpful to know what needs to be included to help others be honest. Thank you too for being willing to share your creativity and talents with us even though there are those who would steal. Love to you and yours.

Melissa Taylor said...

Cassi did the same for me and I can't thank her enough but I'm fuming mad. I seriously can't believe that anyone would steal -- those are my words, my kids work, my hard work. It's such a violation. And this woman says she's a homeschooling Catholic. Doubtful. Great post - I'll tweet it to everyone I know.

Melissa
http://imaginationsoup.net

rachel whetzel said...

It's so frustrating, because really? How hard is it to maybe take a small quote and LINK to the full article?! It's not! It's lazy and selfish. I have yet to request to use a photo or information from a fellow blogger (with credit given etc.) and not gotten a yes. JUST ASK, people!!

And on that note, make ASKING easy. It's so frustrating not to have an easy to find contact information on sites.

Wendy said...

That same "blogger" stole one of my tutorials, too! Thanks to Cassi/The Crafty Crow and another sharp reader for letting me know about it. And thanks to ZenCrafting for sharing this info and helping rightful copyright owners stick up for themselves.

Nanou said...

Sorry to ear you have been stolen, Pat ! It's a real problem, especially when you are talented. Unscrupulous people makes me so angry, I find it very discouraging and I feel so helpless. It's good that your firnd Cassi could help you a little bit. The web has such wonderful aspects (such as weeting you) and disgusting ones ! I hope this case will be dealth soon ...

Sonia said...

my dear friend, I'm so sorry to read that, and it makes me so angry that some people has so few originality & education for simply cutting & pasting everything they see online. It happens too often nowadays. The internet has opened the best doors ever but also the meanest ones, very sadly.
I am currently away from home & got your email when it was too late for me to make a proper blog post about it, but I will talk about it in my next blog post.
oxox

Jane (and Lou) said...

Oh THANKYOU, I didn't realise that others were having the same problem too as sometimes I feel that I'm the only one. I mean seriously people have SPONSORED sites and make money off my work by posting it and my blog isn't sponsored. I don't care for an image of mine with a tiny little word that says 'source' either. Someone had the audacity to suggest that the internet is a poor man's copyright - whatever that means and someone else told me that if I didn't want it out there I shouldn't put it on the internet! Thanks for sharing your journey and for being part of the solution. Jane:)

Wendy said...

Thank you for posting this. This has happened to me too.

With gratitude,
Wendy

jackie said...

uuuggghh!! as usual you have done some research and have offered some very good suggestions to the rest of us should we find ourselves in a similar situation. sorry that all of your hard work was passed off as someone else's. It sounds as if Margie did not have a successful outcome with the Etsy rip off. shame on those people!!

jackie said...

oh my gosh! i just went to the post pointed out by dynamic2moms. outrageous!! i just had to leave a comment berating this woman for what she is doing!

balmeras said...

Thanks so much for sharing this! I had a entire series hijacked by Tugs Nature. When I asked her to take it down, she took down one post, and then just renamed the series and left 15 posts up. Let me know if I can help in the charge in any way!

Cheers- Bethe @balmeras
www.grassstainguru.com

Tina and Kelley said...

THANK YOU to all of YOU. Tug of Nature must have felt the pressure (hee hee no pun intended) she has now marked her blog as PRIVATE. She should have marked it as "Pilferer". lol

I guess I am the sort of person who does not desire to build followers, numbers or stats by lying,deceiving and thievery!

It's people with REAL hearts who are blessed by all the work each of us share.

I would rather only inspire 10 people who were BLESSED by my work than 100 who were not.

Thank YOU Pat for this blog and Cassie and Jackie and did I miss somebody for letting their voice be heard? This has NOT diminished my heart for sharing but only heightened it!

Lori said...

Wonderful post. It's not the first time my work has been stolen, but it is still infuriating. My work is copyrighted, there's a copyright statement on my blog. The material is going into a future book. Yet she stole the words AND the photos.

I don't know how you would claim ignorance on this. My young sons are confused -- they point out that they learned it was wrong to take credit for someone else's work in preschool.

Slow Family Online said...

Wordpress has taken "Tug at Nature" down. The site was quite shamelessly stealing nearly every blog post, from all kinds of sources. I think the fact that it was removed speaks volumes about the ultimate power of the blogging community to protect its rights. Keep on, creative, vibrant bloggers! I look forward to reading and sharing.

Anonymous said...

Does it really matter? Surely all that you are saying is that your ego suffers because we don't know it is 'your' post? Why not be a nice person and just let it go? Anyone can have ideas - they don't belong to the person who had them; there is rarely an original thought - many will have had them before and will again. This is just being overly precious. If you care so much then don't put stuff online. It becomes obvious from posts such as this that acclaim is the reason stuff is put up online and not because it is done in the spirit of sharing. Your prerogative of course but I find it annoying that it is pretended otherwise.